It's long time since he left his English,____?[A] didn't he[B] hadn't he[C] wasn't it[D] isn't it我不知道是怎么判断的,这题应该是反意疑问句.但是我不明白的是这里.就是带从句的反意疑问句,那逗号后面的结尾

来源:学生作业帮助网 编辑:作业帮 时间:2024/04/29 16:49:32
It's long time since he left his English,____?[A] didn't he[B] hadn't he[C] wasn't it[D] isn't it我不知道是怎么判断的,这题应该是反意疑问句.但是我不明白的是这里.就是带从句的反意疑问句,那逗号后面的结尾

It's long time since he left his English,____?[A] didn't he[B] hadn't he[C] wasn't it[D] isn't it我不知道是怎么判断的,这题应该是反意疑问句.但是我不明白的是这里.就是带从句的反意疑问句,那逗号后面的结尾
It's long time since he left his English,____?
[A] didn't he
[B] hadn't he
[C] wasn't it
[D] isn't it
我不知道是怎么判断的,这题应该是反意疑问句.
但是我不明白的是这里.就是带从句的反意疑问句,那逗号后面的结尾是按照主句It's long time 的否定写还是按照since he left his English的否定写?
是不是所有的这种情况逗号后面都按照主句改呢?

It's long time since he left his English,____?[A] didn't he[B] hadn't he[C] wasn't it[D] isn't it我不知道是怎么判断的,这题应该是反意疑问句.但是我不明白的是这里.就是带从句的反意疑问句,那逗号后面的结尾
选D.这里是要按主句的,没错.
但不是所有情况下都是按主句的,具体是根据逻辑确定到底要对什么进行反问.就这个句子的逻辑来讲,上面的说话的人和听的人都应该知道he left his English这件事的,所以不需要反问这个.但是如果句子改成这样就不同了:
I think he has left his English.
就这里的逻辑来讲,就不能跟随主句了,你不需要反问你是不是这样认为的,所以应该是:
I think he has left his English,hasn't he?
如果改成这样:
He thought she had left her English.就跟随主句或从句都符合逻辑了.试比较:
He thought she had left her English,didn't he?(他不是这样认为吗?)
He thought she had left her English,hadn't she?(她没有放弃英语吗?)

前面是It's, 后面就要变成 isn't it?. 就像中文说"不是吗"一样,

这道题的答案就告诉你了,应该看主句。
主句是it's long time
反义疑问句是:isn't it

hadn't 选 B

当然是按照主句啦,从句可以不理,所以主句是肯定的话,疑问就是否定咯